Here is a simple
approach to what appears to be a big s'teerah between the 400 years in
Mitzrayim as per Torah Shebichtav, vs. the 210 years as per TSBP.
[Note: I'm not addressing the case of 430 years, but one can extrapolate an answer from this approach]
Rashi [Lech Lecha 15:13] suggests that the 400 years in a "Land not theirs" commences with the birth of Yitzchak, and that the actual descent to Mitzrayim actually comes 190 years later.
Extrapolating from Rashi here is my approach:
There are "2 dinnim" re: Egypt
1. The physical Land of Egypt
2. The extended Empire of Egypt.
Background:
Modern Archaeologists consider the Ancient Land of Canaan during that era as under the influence [Suzerainty] of the Egyptian Empire, perhaps similar to Poland used to be when it was under the Soviet Sphere of influence.
So, in a sense, during those first 190 years, the Avot were not in the physical Land of Egypt, yet the galut of the Empire of Egypt indeed did start earlier on - because Canaan was under the Social and Political Influence of Egypt, and by extension they were in a "Spiritual Galus Mitzrayim."
And so both figures work.
210 years in Physical Egypt
400 years as subject to Egyptian Social Mores.
[Note: I'm not addressing the case of 430 years, but one can extrapolate an answer from this approach]
Rashi [Lech Lecha 15:13] suggests that the 400 years in a "Land not theirs" commences with the birth of Yitzchak, and that the actual descent to Mitzrayim actually comes 190 years later.
Extrapolating from Rashi here is my approach:
There are "2 dinnim" re: Egypt
1. The physical Land of Egypt
2. The extended Empire of Egypt.
Background:
Modern Archaeologists consider the Ancient Land of Canaan during that era as under the influence [Suzerainty] of the Egyptian Empire, perhaps similar to Poland used to be when it was under the Soviet Sphere of influence.
So, in a sense, during those first 190 years, the Avot were not in the physical Land of Egypt, yet the galut of the Empire of Egypt indeed did start earlier on - because Canaan was under the Social and Political Influence of Egypt, and by extension they were in a "Spiritual Galus Mitzrayim."
And so both figures work.
210 years in Physical Egypt
400 years as subject to Egyptian Social Mores.
Kol Tuv,
RRW
No comments:
Post a Comment